Nomato pasta sauce blends roasted butternut squash, carrots, shallots, cherries, and cranberries into a naturally sweet and tangy nightshade-free sauce.

Creamy butternut nomato pasta sauce over spaghetti topped with fresh basil

A Versatile Sauce Without Tomatoes

This nomato sauce recipe is for anyone who needs or wants a tomato-free option without giving up familiar meals.

Butternut squash and carrots create the creamy base, while cherries and cranberries provide the sweet-tart balance that tomatoes usually bring.

I serve it with chickpea or lentil pasta, but it also works for pizza, lasagna, stuffed vegetables, or any dish that would normally use jarred tomato sauce. Roasting does most of the work, and the blender turns everything into a smooth, versatile staple.

Forkful of spaghetti coated in butternut nomato pasta sauce

Javant’s Health Tips

Butternut squash and carrots provide carotenoids, including beta-carotene, which the body can convert to vitamin A to support vision, immune function, and normal cell growth. Cherries and cranberries add colorful polyphenols and acidity without refined sugar.

This sauce is intended as an option for people who avoid or do not tolerate nightshades; tomatoes and other nightshades are not inherently unhealthy for people who tolerate them.

Labeled butternut squash, carrots, shallots, garlic, cherries, cranberries, herbs and broth for nomato pasta sauce

Key Ingredients and Substitutions

  • Butternut squash – Creates the body of the sauce.
  • Cherries and cranberries – Provide a sweet-tart balance; fresh or frozen fruit works.
  • Low-sodium broth – Add only as much as needed for your preferred consistency.
  • Chickpea or lentil pasta – Optional for serving and adds more fiber and plant protein than many refined pastas.

Make Your Own Nomato Pasta Sauce

  1. Prepare the vegetables. Place squash cut-side down on a lined tray; wrap shallots and garlic in parchment and add chopped carrots.
Butternut squash, chopped carrots and parchment-wrapped aromatics ready to roast
  1. Roast. Bake at 425℉ for about 45 minutes, until everything is tender.
Roasted butternut squash and carrots on a parchment-lined baking tray
  1. Add to the blender. Scoop in the squash and add carrots, shallots, garlic, cherries, cranberries, herbs, and broth.
Cherries, cranberries, herbs and roasted vegetables in a blender for nomato sauce
  1. Blend. Process until completely smooth, adding broth only as needed.
Smooth orange nomato pasta sauce in a stainless-steel blender pitcher
  1. Serve. Toss with chickpea or lentil pasta or use for pizza, lasagna, or another tomato-free dish.
Bowl of spaghetti served with butternut nomato sauce and fresh basil

Keys to Making Great Nomato Pasta Sauce

  1. Roast until very tender. Soft vegetables blend into the smoothest sauce.
  2. Start with less broth. You can thin the sauce, but it is harder to thicken after blending.
  3. Blend thoroughly. A high-speed blender creates the creamiest result.
  4. Taste before salting. Broth and pasta may already contribute sodium.

Storing and Reheating

Cool completely and refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 5 days.

Freeze in meal-size portions for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight and reheat over medium-low heat, stirring in broth or water as needed.

Store cooked pasta separately so it does not absorb all the sauce.

Close-up of spaghetti coated in creamy nomato pasta sauce with basil

Frequently Asked Questions

Does it taste like tomato sauce?

It has a sweet-tart balance reminiscent of tomato sauce. Familiar Italian seasonings add the savory flavor you expect, while the squash and fruit give it a distinct taste.

Can I use it on pizza or lasagna?

Yes. Keep it slightly thicker for pizza and lasagna, and thin it more for pasta.

Is this recipe only for people avoiding nightshades?

No. Anyone can enjoy it, but it is especially useful when a tomato-free sauce is needed.

Related Recipes

Creamy butternut nomato pasta sauce over spaghetti topped with fresh basil
No ratings yet

Creamy Butternut Nomato Pasta Sauce

6 cups
A creamy nightshade-free sauce made with roasted butternut squash, carrots, cherries, and cranberries.
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 45 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour

Ingredients
 

Instructions
 

  • Preheat. Heat the oven to 425℉ and line a baking sheet with parchment.
  • Arrange. Place the squash cut-side down on the tray. Wrap the shallots and garlic in parchment and add them with the chopped carrots.
  • Roast. Bake for about 45 minutes, until the carrots and squash are tender.
  • Blend. Add the roasted ingredients, cherries, cranberries, seasonings, and broth to a blender. Blend until completely smooth.
  • Serve. Use over cooked chickpea or lentil pasta, or as a sauce for pizza, lasagna, stuffed vegetables, and other dishes.

Video

Please Note: I occasionally update my recipes after filming the videos. For the most accurate and up-to-date ingredients and instructions, always refer to the written recipe.

Notes

  • Consistency: Use less broth for pizza or lasagna and more for pasta.
  • Nightshade-free garnish: Red pepper flakes are a nightshade; omit them when strict avoidance is needed.
  • Nutrition: Nutrition information is intentionally omitted from this post.
Did you make this recipe?Please consider Leaving a star rating and review!